RAHA

Home

Author Index

WORLD INDEPENDENT WRITERS' HOME

RAHA Charter - RAHA Membership - RAHA Book - Professional Literature - Literary Criticism - Opinion

 Poetry - Short Story - Author Index -  News World-class literature - Letter to Editor - Interview

 Writers in exile - Amateur literature - RAHA Gift - Link to RAHA  - Frog Books - Contact Us


Literary Criticism

   

 

 Kabul Press, World Media Home

 

 

A quick glance on Novel The Kite Runner

Author of the novel: Khaled Hosseini

Crow knows the language of the crow

                                                            Afghan proverb

Unbiased and open minded readers only, please!

Actually, the real novel writer is articulator of the dark corners, unspoken, and untouched aspects of the horizontal and vertical socio-cultural domains of a society that can not be found in an official cultural social, geographical, or political books. The real novel writer is pointing the most important and crucial problem or question of the time in a society. If a novel becomes a tool for blotting; insulting; devaluating of the real values and measures of a nation, or a specific ethnic group, gaining some other financial and political interests and benefits, it could be very dangerous, discriminatory, insane, seditious and/or inflammable.

Socio-cultural and ethical values and measures of a society, honestly kept during the evolution and development of the story, could be developed progressively during the span of the story. If a novel or story is lacking these characters, it would not be a real one. Events, developments and evolutions in a non-real novel or story theoretically are possible, but in practice are not applicable. 

One of the important elements that has its special place in a novel is the imagination on the bases of the actual geographic, social, cultural, economical, psychological, and social psychology realities. If these imaginations are not laid on these bases, they can not find their place amongst society.

Ethnic supremacy and priorities, shows selfishness, short-sightedness, narrow-mindedness, and dogmatism only, while in every society there are many ethnic groups. Recognition of persons, in a specific ethnic group or a nation has its own importance and beauty in a dialectical relationship with other ethnic groups or nations in a wide range of human beings and is possible through an academic practical and strategic methodology. If there is an experimental mistake, it is a great lesson, if it is intentional, how unforgivable and irreparable it would be.

Being literate only, is not sufficient to claim of being a real novel writer or poet or artist. The novel is the most complex and developed genre of literature which needs the precise, correct and complete knowledge of history, philosophy, history of religion, culture,  politics, economics, socio-psychology and etc. Hereinafter, the real novel writer is an impartial depositor, honest, responsible undertaker of the highest values and measures of humanity and pointing the main problem and paradox of the society and time. The real novel writer is trying and searching to articulate and shows the ways of resolving the paradoxes with a dynamic system of research.

Hereinafter, the measuring and criticizing of a novel needs the specific way of consumption and a thorough capacity of that knowledge. If a person or institutions are lacking of this capacity and capability, measuring or criticizing a novel irresponsibly, can not tell you more then:

"A beautiful novel... ranks among the best-written and provocative stories of the year so far. . . a heartbreaking story of [an] unlikely friendship. . . This unusually eloquent story is also about the fragile relationship between fathers and sons, humans and their gods, men and their countries. Loyalty and blood are the ties that bind their stories into one of the most lyrical, moving and unexpected books this year."

-The Denver Post

 "A marvelous first novel. . . the story of two young boys who are friends in Afghanistan, and an incredible story of the culture. It's an old-fashioned kind of novel that really sweeps you away."   -San Francisco Chronicle

 

               "It is so powerful that for a long time everything I read seemed bland."    -Isabel Allende

"Brilliant, startling plot twists make this book memorable both as a political chronicle and a deeply personal tale about how childhood choices affect our adult lives. The character studies alone would make this a noteworthy debut, from the portrait of the sensitive, insecure Amir to the multilayered development of his father, Baba, whose sacrifices and scandalous behavior are fully revealed only when Amir returns to Afghanistan and learns the history and its ramifications in both America and the Middle East. . . The result is a complete work of literature that succeeds in exploring the culture of a previously obscure nation that has become a pivotal point in the global politics of a new millennium. It is rare that a book is at once so timely and of such high literary quality."

                                                         -"Publishers Weekly (starred review)

"A more personal plot, arising from Amir's close friendship with Hassan, the son of his father's servant, turns out to be the thread that ties the book together. The fragility of this relationship, symbolized by the kites the boys fly together, is tested as they watch their old way of life disappear. Hosseini's depiction of pre-revolutionary Afghanistan is rich in warmth and humor but also tense with the friction between the nation's different ethnic grouRs. . . . Full of haunting images: a man, desperate to feed his children, trying to sell his artificial leg in the market; an adulterous couple stoned to death in a stadium during the halftime of a football match; a rouged young boy forced into prostitution, dancing the sort of steps once performed by an organ grinder's monkey." -The New York Times

"It is not so much a story of Mideast politics. . . as it is a story of life in a beautiful country torn asunder. Through his characters and the plot, which is captivating and at times quite disturbing, Hosseini offers a lesson on his culture and the history of his beloved homeland."                         

                                                             -San Antonio Express-News

"The frame of the story is the rhythm of life. This novel, set in Afghanistan in the 1970s and later in America, is a work of universal interest because of the literary genius of Khaled Hosseini. The culmination of the novel, too brutal and beautiful to reveal, demonstrates the author's capacity to bring life full circle in a great arc of grace and redeeming activity. A profound work of literature with a rare healing power."

                                                        -The Buffalo News

"Khaled Hosseini brings his native country to life with great sensitivity. [He] richly describes the Afghan customs and traditions that tug on the immigrants as they mourn the loss of their country and struggle to build an American life. In The Kite Runner Hosseini has created a wise, thoughtful book in which redemption and happiness are not necessarily the same thing."

                                                                 -Houston Chronicle

"This extraordinary novel locates the personal struggles of everyday people in the terrible sweep of history."                                                            -People

 

"Evocative. . . acute and genuine... One of the great strengths of The Kite Runner is its sympathetic portrayal of Afghans and Afghan culture. Hosseini writes with warmth and enviable familiarity about Afghanistan and its people. . . a descriptive and easily readable account."          -Chicago Tribune

"A powerful book. . . no frills, no nonsense, just hard spare prose. . . An intimate account of family and friendship, betrayal and salvation that requires no atlas or translation to engage and enlighten us. Parts of The Kite Runner are raw and excruciating to read, yet the book in its entirety is lovingly written. Hosseini clearly loves his country as much as he hates what has become of it . . . A tale told in simple brush strokes, closer to Kawabata's Thousand Cranes than Mahfouz's Trilogy. Hosseini is at his best describing moments of slow, silent agony."

                                                         -The Washington Post Book World

"Demonstrates a love of storytelling and respect for literary writing in equal measures. . . a big-hearted book with plenty of winning qualities. One of the most appealing aspects of this novel is its deceptively simple prose. Like Waiting, Ha Jin's novel of love, politics and class issues, The Kite Runner blesses readers with guileless storytelling."

                                                             -The Cleveland Plain Dealer

"A gripping and moving book that offers a surprising reward: an understanding of, and empathy for, the people of Afghanistan. . . The book's power resides in Hosseini's ability to bring that culture to life on the page. . . almost impossible to put down."         

                                                                     -Iowa City Press

"A vivid picture of Afghanistan thirty years ago."

                                                                                  -The Wall Street Journal

"Hosseini shows how an engaging novel begins-with simple, exquisite writing that compels the reader to turn the page."                  -The Philadelphia Inquirer

"Provides an extraordinary perspective on the struggles of a country that, until that doleful September day, had been for too long ignored or misunderstood. And despite its grimmer episodes, the novel ends with a note of optimism about Afghanistan's future, an optimism that the whole world would prefer to see unspoiled.    -BookPage

"Hosseini does tenderness and terror, California dream, and Kabul nightmare with equal aplomb. . . . A ripping yarn and ethical parable."                                                                -Globe and Mail

"From the first lines of The Kite Runner, Khaled Hosseini shows how an engaging novel begins-with simple, exquisite writing that compels the reader to turn the page. . . . A wonderfully conjured story that offers a glimpse into Afghanistan most Americans have never seen, and depicts a side of the humanity rarely revealed."                -Contra Costa Times

"Here's a real find: a striking debut from an Afghan now living in the U.S. His passionate story of betrayal and redemption is framed by Afghanistan's tragic recent past. . . . Rather than settle for a coming-of-age or travails-of-immigrant story, Hosseini has folded them both into this searing spectacle of hardwon personal salvation. All this, and a rich slice of Afghan culture too: irresistible."                                                                 -Kirkus Reviews (starred review)

"Provides a vivid glimpse of life in Afghanistan over the past quarter century. The characters of Amir and his father, their relationships, and the relationship of Hassan and Amir are all carefully and convincingly described and developed. Hosseini, now a doctor in California, is possibly the only Afghan author writing in English, and his first novel is recommended."

                                                                     -Library Journal

If somebody asks crucial and essential questions, simply, they can not answer or make some general comments. According to a master of literature, They are like empty carrier bags. If you shake them, only small particles will be floating randomly in the air.

I hope, as a very ordinary reader of the book, to have the permission to see the scenes, events, courses of evolutions and developments of the story from the middle of society upward to the top of the pyramids of institutions.

I would be more than grateful to receive your constructive criticism and suggestions in this matter, regardless of what it is.

Sincerely yours and begging your pardons,

Safar A. Hanif,

Safar_h2000@yahoo.com

  Page 1    2    3            Next

 

Safar A. Hanif

Raha PEN

18/3/2006

 Page 1 of 3

 

 

 

 

 

 

As the mind has no boundaries, the RAHA concept does not have frontiers and is opposed to information and cultural control by global communication entities whether media conglomerates, states or local governments, or religions

From independent writers to independent readers

RAHA- World Independent Writers' Home


Copyright RAHA- World Independent Writers' Home 2000-2006/ Authors